Peace of Mind for Our Investors Is Our TOP Priority


We are proud to provide the best Orlando area property management and sales of residential homes! We combine our knowledge for the industry in this area with traditional hands-on property management and state of the art online tools to deliver our homeowners all the information they need with a click of a button.

Alternatively, you can pick up the phone and talk to us.  Most of our homeowners started with listing their homes as short term vacation rentals and when they realized how many cancellations and repairs they were saddled with… they looked for a better solution and found us.

Are you working with an Orlando property management company that shows your home to prospective tenants personally? We want to get a feel for applicants to ensure we choose the family that will look after your home as if were their own home.

We have professionally vetted and checked the employment, credit and background of thousands of applicants over the years and only the best make the cut. So you can have peace of mind knowing that seasoned property managers are working hard for you… and when it comes time to sell we can walk you through that process as well!


While there are many rental and letting agents in the Kissimmee, FL area, there are few that stand out as exceptional. Our team really raises the bar when it comes to quality service. 

Anne-Marie Opened McCormack Realty in Kissimmee Florida in 1991. She has evolved the business alongside her client’s needs starting with vacation rentals and sales, then adding long term property rentals and now focuses solely on long-term rentals and real estate sales.

Nicole Salvador started with McCormack realty as an Administrative Assistant in 2004, through her dedication to the company, clients, and tenants she has evolved right alongside Anne-Marie. Nicole is now the main Property Manager and a Licensed Realtor.

Nicholas McCormack dedicates himself to ensuring our state of the art property management portal, servers, and maintenance ticketing systems are running in tip-top shape. His official roles are Accountant, Director of IT, and support for our clients and tenants.

Pete Haslam

Verified customer through TrustPilot

Great company! Looked after leasing my house in Florida for many years. Recently listed my property sold with 3 days and monies were sent to my bank within 6 weeks.

Amazingly smooth transaction. Anne Marie has been a pleasure to deal with every step of the way. Thank you.




Our rental homeowners are raving about a new rental protection program that we’re offering. There’s a new way for you to make a sound financial return on your home in Orlando, Kissimmee or Davenport Florida. We can help you protect your rental income for up to 12 months. Ask us about our rent protection program only available for our rental homeowners.


We will rent your home within 30 days or your first month’s management fee is on us! Typical tenant procurement time is less than two weeks! We spend time and money on an individual advertising campaign for each home by utilising the most advanced listing system and online marketing program for your property.


All our owners tell us we are the most cost effective management company they’ve ever had! We  specialize in reducing your running costs and maximizing your rental income. There are no mystery charges on your management statement and you can keep tabs on what we’re doing with your tenants and property 24/7 through our online portal. Transparency and trust are not just words, they’re fundamental to the way we run our company.


When a tenant needs something fixing, we’ll send you an email so you know what’s going on. Depending on your management program we may take photos of before and after photos as well as uploading the invoice to your owner portal. Detailed property inspections are also available and with these we can send you a report complete with photo’s. 

I’ve been living in a rental from this company for 5 years now and it’s been the best living situation I’ve ever been in. They are quick to respond, easy to get problems fixed, and very understanding. I can’t suggest a property from this company enough!

Dawn McLaughlin – Tenant

We have been renting off Renter’s Choice for over 4 years now and we have never had any issues. All requests are dealt with promptly and the team are so nice and easy to work with.

Jake – Tenant

We have rented from this company for sometime and never had we had a problem communicating with them. They are quick to respond to any maintenance request or issues we may have. During the pandemic, they were very understanding and helpful for the time we were not working. From Anne Marie, Nicole and everyone in the office to the maintenance guys, they are great!!

Jenny Lizardo – Tenant

Deborah Dickings

Verified customer through TrustPilot

I cannot rate McCormack Realty & Renters Choice Homes highly enough. Anne-Marie, Nicole, Nick and the team provide excellent customer service, they are friendly, efficient, always ready to answer your questions, advise and assist you. They have managed our property for the last 7 years and I can honestly say you will not find a better company to look after your property. Highly recommended.